Re: DNSO Dilemma

Michael Sondow (msondow@iciiu.org)
Wed, 23 Dec 1998 02:42:32 -0500


David Schutt a écrit:
>
> There is, of course, a solution to the incorporation dilemma.
>
> Join the general membership of ICANN, and form an advisory committee on DNS
> matters.
>
> Given the risks and lack of benefits, plus the duplication of effort
> involved in a separate DNSO, it may be worth considering.

Yes, of course, this is precisely what the original, acceptable ICANN bylaws
created: the SOs as advisory bodies with the ICANN and actually forming the
components of it, with the chosen leaders of the SOs being the Board, except for
some Board members being selected by an at-large membership that couldn't fit in
any SO. Now that's been turned on its head, with the ICANN membership separate
from the SO memberships. This is a whole new ball game, and the SOs are
isolated, stripped of power, and liable for their own policies.

>
> David Schutt
> Speco, Inc.