Kent,
Excellent job on the charter. You took out all the useless venting I put
in and made it clear, readable, and operational.
I second Bill Semich's motion that we vote this in as is. Personally I
would still put in something about the duties of the POC reps, but we could
always add that later if necessary.
Antony
At 07:51 AM 2/4/98 +0000, J. William Semich wrote:
>I have read this thoroughly and it is exactly what we need. If there are
>any small problems with it, I think we should modify it down the road.
>There's little time for doing much else, IMHO.
>
>I move that we accept this charter as it stands (unchanged) and I call
>for a vote.
>
>Is there a second?
>
>Assuming this is the appropriate process. If not, tell me what is and
>I'll modify my motion <smile>
>
>Let's get moving!
>
>Regards,
>
>Bill Semich
>Internet Users Society
>
>In reply to 2 Feb message from Kent Crispin <kent@songbird.com>:
>
>>Only a few hours late, here is a copy of the draft charter that I
>>have seriously hacked. My apologies to Antony, in advance.
>
>>Please read it carefully -- I would like to do a consensus call on
>>it within the next couple of weeks. That call will be to bless it
>>as a charter, which means it is what we live with until we do
>>something better. So special attention might be paid to the
>>section on how the charter may be modified.
>
>>I am attaching a text version. It is a conversion of the html
>>document I actually prepared, which can be seen at
>>http://songbird.com/pab/dc.html (dc = draft charter. Unix, you
>>know.)
>
>>I am pushing this because I have a hint that the GP authors may
>>not have really looked at PAB, and PAB can be seen as one of the
>>strong points of the MoU organization -- it is a body chartered to
>>be receptive to public input -- always a good selling point in
>>politics. So it would be good if we had our house in order.
>
>>This may seem like a lot to deal with in a short time. It *is* a
>>lot to deal with in a short time.
>
>>There is a 30 day window for comment on the GP, remember. You
>>should be thinking about your comments...
>
>>Here's the charter:
>
>>-----------------------------------------------------------
>>PAB CHARTER
>
>>1. Contents
>
>> 1. Contents
>>
>> 2. Definitions
>>
>> 3. PAB Role Under the gTLD-MoU
>>
>> 4. PAB Mission
>>
>> 5. PAB Deliberation and Debate
>>
>> 6. PAB Officers
>>
>> 1. Election of Officers, Their Eligibility and Terms of
>>Office
>>
>> 2. Removal of Officers
>>
>> 3. Duties of Officers
>>
>> 7. Modification of the PAB Charter
>>
>> 8. Appendix 1: PAB Voting Mechanism
>
>>2. Definitions
>
>> 1. PAB: Policy Advisory Body, a body defined under the
>>gTLD-MoU
>> Structure
>>
>> 2. POC: Policy Oversight Committee, a body defined under the
>> gTLD-MoU Structure
>>
>> 3. CORE: Council of Registrars, a body defined under the
>>gTLD-MoU
>> structure
>>
>> 4. GTLD-MoU: generic Top-Level Domain Memorandum of
>>Understanding
>>
>> 5. PAB Member: an individual representative of a signatory of
>>the
>> gTLD-MoU that has elected participate in the PAB
>>
>> 6. Active PAB Members: those PAB members who are subscribed
>>to
>> the PAB mailing list, and who therefore may vote using the
>> mechanism referenced below
>>
>> 7. PAB Representatives on POC: any PAB Member who is elected
>>by
>> the PAB Membership to serve on POC
>>
>> 8. rough consensus: the model of direct democracy practiced
>>by
>> the IETF.
>
>>3. PAB Role Under the gTLD-MoU
>
>> 1. As defined by the gTLD-MoU (Section 5), the role of the
>>PAB is
>> to make recommendations to the POC regarding general policy
>> matters, and to advise the POC with regard to changes in the
>> gTLD-MoU and the CORE-MoU.
>
>>4. PAB Mission
>
>> 1. The Policy Advisory Body exists to represent the widest
>> possible set of Internet stakeholders in the administration of
>>the
>> global Internet domain name system, as limited by the
>>gTLD-MoU.
>> The PAB actively solicits, debates, and where possible reaches
>> consensual positions on how the global Internet domain system
>> should be administered, and it reports its advice and
>> recommendations to the POC.
>
>> 2. The PAB is a vehicle for bringing into the gTLD-MoU
>>process
>> those groups and organizations that are not otherwise
>>represented
>> within its framework, and is therefore a fertile ground for
>>the
>> introduction of new ideas, and for the inclusion of new
>>interest
>> groups.
>
>> 3. The PAB is furthermore a mechanism through which dissent
>> against the existing gTLD-MoU structure can be expressed, and
>>thus
>> can be powerful catalyst for change.
>
>> 4. The PAB recognizes that the gTLD-MoU does not provide for
>> oversight of the POC, and therefore the PAB has a special duty
>>to
>> give advice and make recommendations regarding the role and
>> function of the POC.
>
>> 5. The PAB reserves to itself all powers not specifically
>> prohibited by the gTLD-MoU.
>
>>5. PAB Deliberation, Debate, and Decisions
>
>> 1. The basic model for PAB as a deliberative body is that of
>> rough consensus, as practiced by the IETF.
>
>> 2. All discussion and deliberation shall take place via an
>>echoed
>> email list, whose administration shall be entrusted to the
>> Secretary of the PAB.
>
>> 3. An archive of the email list may, at the discretion of the
>> Active PAB Membership, be made available to the public.
>
>> 4. There shall be no limitation on what a PAB Member may
>>write on
>> the PAB list; nor shall any censorship be imposed on PAB
>>Members;
>> and no PAB Member shall be removed from the list except at its
>>own
>> request. However, while content is not controlled in any way,
>> quantity of submissions may be, if the list is overloaded. In
>> such a case, all controls will be applied equally to all
>>members.
>> [For example, the list may be restricted to 5 posts a day per
>> member, or 100KB/day per member, or some such equitable
>> restriction.]
>
>> 5. On occasion formal elections may be held. All such
>>elections
>> shall be conducted using the PAB voting mechanism, described
>>in a
>> separate section. Generally, there are two classes of
>>elections:
>> "yes/no" elections for policy issues, and election of
>>officers,
>> though other classes are not ruled out. Policy elections are
>>held
>> on demand as part of a consensus process; officer elections
>>are
>> held according to different rules, described in the section on
>> election of officers.
>
>> 6. In addition, straw polls may be called. Straw polls are
>>not
>> binding, and are generally held for information gathering
>> purposes. Straw polls will not be further discussed; all
>>further
>> reference to elections or votes will refer to those involving
>>the
>> PAB voting mechanism.
>
>> 7. The PAB shall arrive at recommendations, advice,
>>resolutions,
>> internal policies, and other common positions by rough
>>consensus
>> methods, as follows:
>
>> 1. The Chair may attempt to determine a consensus
>>concerning
>> a given issue by announcing a Call for Consensus to the
>>PAB
>> list. The Chair must announce a Call for Consensus on a
>>given
>> issue if 10% or more PAB members request it of the Chair.
>
>> 2. After a reasonable period of debate, generally not
>>less
>> than one week and not more than one month, the Chair shall
>> announce either that a preliminary consensus has been
>>reached
>> or that it has not been reached.
>
>> 3. If the Chair announces that a preliminary consensus
>>has
>> been reached, then following the Chair's announcement, a
>> reasonable period, generally not less than one week, shall
>>pass
>> in order to allow dissenting views to be heard.
>
>> 1. If 10% or more of the Active PAB Membership
>>dissents
>> from the Chair's announcement of a preliminary
>>consensus,
>> the Chair shall have the option of either tabling the
>> proposition or calling for an election on the
>>preliminary
>> consensus by informing the PAB list.
>
>> 2. If less than 10% of the Active PAB Membership
>>dissents
>> from the Chair's announcement of a preliminary
>>consensus,
>> the Chair shall announce that a final consensus has
>>been
>> reached, and the Chair shall, if appropriate,
>>communicate
>> the results to the POC. The Chair may further
>>instruct
>> the Secretary to add the results to the PAB web site,
>>and
>> also communicate the results to the public by whatever
>> other method the Chair at its sole discretion may deem
>> advisable.
>
>> 4. If the Chair announces that a preliminary
>>consensus has
>> not been reached, and the Chair does not decide to
>>seek an
>> election on the matter, it may continue to be debated
>>on
>> the PAB list, but the Chair may not be compelled to
>>seek
>> another consensus on the matter for three months. But
>>if
>> the Chair decides that with small modification a
>>consensus
>> could be reached on the matter, the Chair has an
>> affirmative duty to find the correct compromise that
>>will
>> allow a consensus to be reached.
>
>> 5. In the event that the Chair announces that a
>> preliminary consensus has not been reached, the Chair
>>may
>> determine, at the Chair's discretion, that the matter
>>is
>> important or timely enough that a definitive position
>>by
>> the PAB is required. Examples of such important or
>>timely
>> matters might be: a request from the POC for a
>> recommendation, or a matter that is of clear and
>>pressing
>> importance. In such cases, the Chair may call for an
>> election on the matter. The election shall be carried
>>out
>> using the PAB voting mechanism, and notice shall be
>>given
>> to all Active PAB Members at least one week before the
>> election takes place.
>
>> 1. If 67% or more of the Voting PAB Members are
>>in
>> favor of the proposition being voted upon, the
>> proposition shall have passed, and the Chair shall
>> announce that a Consensus has been reached;
>>otherwise,
>> the proposition shall have failed, and the Chair
>>shall
>> announce that a Consensus has not been reached.
>
>> 2. In the event of an election, each PAB Member
>>shall
>> have one vote.
>
>> 8. An Annual General Meeting of the PAB may be called by the
>> Chair, or by a consensus of the PAB by the usual methods. All
>> decisions and elections must nonetheless be carried out on the
>>PAB
>> list. All PAB Members attending an Annual General Meeting
>>must
>> pay for their own expenses.
>
>>6. PAB Officers
>> The PAB shall elect the following officers:
>> 1. Chair
>> 2. Deputy Chair
>> 3. Secretary
>> 4. Liaison to CORE
>> 5. PAB Representatives to POC
>> These officers together comprise the PAB Executive Committee.
>
>> 2. Election of Officers, Their Eligibility and Terms of
>>Office
>
>> 1. Any member of the PAB can nominate any other member of
>>the
>> PAB to be an Officer of the PAB, subject to the
>>eligibility
>> requirements noted below in this section, by posting a
>> statement to that effect to the PAB list.
>
>> 2. Nominations must be seconded by another member of the
>>PAB
>> by posting a statement to that effect to the PAB list.
>
>> 3. Any person nominated to be a candidate for office in
>>the
>> PAB must accept the nomination by posting a statement to
>>that
>> effect to the PAB list.
>
>> 4. Any candidate who has accepted a nomination to be an
>> officer of the PAB must declare his or her qualifications
>>for
>> the office in question, and to make known to the PAB
>> membership any conflict of interest that he or she is
>>aware
>> of, by posting a statement to that effect to the PAB list.
>> Candidates are encouraged to take a broad view of what
>>might
>> constitute a conflict of interest. Failure to declare a
>> conflict of interest is prima facie evidence of bad faith
>>on
>> the part of the candidate.
>
>> 5. No candidate who is a member of PAB shall be excluded
>>from
>> office in the PAB, except as noted below in this section.
>
>> 6. Officers are to be elected using the PAB voting
>>mechanism
>> via the PAB email list.
>
>> 7. The terms of all officers are to be one year from the
>>date
>> of their election.
>
>> 8. Any PAB member is eligible to be an Officer of PAB,
>> except:
>
>> 1. Members of the PAB who have signed the CORE-MoU,
>>or
>> whose employer has signed the CORE-MoU.
>
>> 2. Members of the PAB who are also members of POC,
>>unless
>> they have been elected to the POC by the PAB.
>
>> 3. Members of the PAB who are employed by
>>organizations
>> which are members of CORE
>
>> 4. Members of the PAB who are employed by
>>organizations
>> which have the power to appoint or elect members of
>>POC,
>> the PAB itself excepted.
>
>> 5. Members of the PAB who hold any executive position
>>in
>> any organization, the PAB itself excepted, which has
>>the
>> power to appoint or elect members of POC.
>
>> 9. The Chair, Deputy Chair, and Secretary must be elected
>>by
>> more than 50% of the PAB Members who vote. In the event
>>that
>> no candidate reaches more than 50%, the two candidates
>> receiving the most votes will meet each other in a run-off
>> election. If the run-off election results in a tie, the
>> chairman of the POC may cast 1 vote to determine the
>>winner.
>
>> 3. Removal of Officers
>
>> 1. The power to remove Officers of the PAB is reserved to
>>the
>> Membership of the PAB. If 25% of the Active PAB Members
>> support a resolution to remove an Officer, the Chair (or,
>>if
>> the Active Members wish to remove the Chair, the Deputy
>>Chair)
>> shall call an election on the issue, to be conducted via
>>the
>> PAB Email list using the voting rules and procedures used
>>for
>> all elections except the election of officers.
>
>> 4. Duties of Officers
>
>> 1. The duties of the Chair shall be as follows:
>
>> 1. To attempt to discern consensus among the PAB, and
>>to
>> call for consensus, and declare a consensus to have
>>been
>> reached, according to the methods described in
>> "Deliberation and Debate" above.
>
>> 2. To make periodic reports, not less than one month
>> apart, to the PAB Membership via the PAB list. The
>> Chair's reports must be comprehensive, and must
>>include
>> summary results of all actions undertaken by the Chair
>>on
>> behalf of PAB, and summary results of all interactions
>> with the POC.
>
>> 3. To make or cause to have made public statements,
>>press
>> releases, and the like.
>
>> 4. In the event that the POC requests PAB's
>> recommendation or advice, the Chair must consult with
>>the
>> membership immediately. If the POC requires a reply
>> before the PAB can reach a consensus, the Chair may
>> communicate his best guess of the PAB's recommendation
>>or
>> advise to the POC, but in such a case the Chair must
>> communicate to the POC that PAB's recommendation is
>> entirely provisional pending ratification by the
>> Membership.
>
>> 2. The duties of the Deputy Chair shall be as follows:
>
>> 1. To assume the function of the Chair temporarily in
>>the
>> event that the Chair is indisposed or unavailable, or,
>>in
>> the case where the Chair has been removed or has
>>resigned,
>> until new elections have been held.
>
>
>> 2. To assume the function of the Chair regarding any
>> measure by the Membership to remove the Chair.
>
>> 3. To perform any duties of the Chair that the Chair
>>may
>> from time to time delegate to the Deputy Chair.
>
>> 3. The duties of the Secretary shall be as follows:
>
>> 1. To maintain the PAB website. The website will
>>include
>> such information as follows:
>
>> * A list of all PAB members
>
>> * A list of the Active PAB Members
>
>> * A list of the PAB officers
>
>> * The text of PAB resolutions
>
>> * A record of the votes in elections, whether for
>> officers or for other matters
>
>> * PAB recommendations and advice to the POC, and
>> responses by the POC as reported by the Chair
>
>> * An archive of PAB email.
>
>> 2. To maintain a copy of this charter, and any
>>subsequent
>> amendments.
>
>> 3. To administer and maintain the echoed email list
>>that
>> the PAB uses to deliberate amongst itself, and any
>>archive
>> of the list that the PAB Membership shall decide to
>>keep
>
>> 4. To administer and maintain the echoed email list
>>that
>> the PAB Executive Committee uses to deliberate amongst
>> itself, and to maintain an archive of this list.
>
>> 5. To maintain a complete list of PAB Members and
>>their
>> designated email addresses, and to respond to PAB
>>Members'
>> requests to modify their designated email addresses,
>>or to
>> subscribe or unsubscribe themselves from the PAB list.
>
>> 4. The duty of the CORE Liaison shall be as follows:
>
>> 1. To inform the PAB Executive Committee of
>>developments
>> within CORE
>
>>7. Modification of the PAB Charter
>
>> 1. This Charter can be modified only by the Membership of the
>> PAB, and by no other body, via the usual methods the PAB
>>employs
>> to determine consensus.
>
>
>
>>Appendix 1: PAB Voting Mechanism
>
>
>>PAB strives to reach rough consensus on an issue before making any
>>recommendation to the POC or taking any other action. At one time
>>or another it will become apparent that there is no consensus on a
>>particular issue and the Chairman will declare that the issue will
>>be put to a vote.
>
>>A draft ballot will be prepared by the Secretary and forwarded to
>>the vote taker.
>
>>The vote taker prepares the final ballot, editing only for
>>consistent wording and compatibility with the voting software.
>
>>Prepared ballots are mailed to the voting contact of all PAB
>>members four times at X day intervals. Using X=3 and having 4
>>days after the mailing of the final ballot gives a two-week voting
>>period.
>
>>(The voting contact is defined as the first, of possibly several,
>>e-mail address an organization has subscribed to the PAB list.)
>
>>Votes are cast by Replying to the ballot e-mail and indicating
>>their choice from the various options available.
>
>>When a completed ballot is received by the vote taker an
>>acknowledgement is returned to the voter. The completed ballot is
>>added to an archive message store established for this one vote
>>and the vote is also parsed and a voting database updated to
>>reflect the ballot.
>
>>If a ballot is deemed unacceptable for any reason it is returned
>>to the sender with an explanation. (In our first vote the only
>>errors encountered were votes from non-voting contacts (these were
>>all resolved) and ballots received after the close of the voting
>>period.)
>
>>Please note that all decisions are built into the voting software,
>>no allowances are made for any reason.
>
>>A voting member may submit multiple ballots, the last ballot
>>received is the only one counted.
>
>>At the end of the voting period the results are tabulated and an
>>e-mail containing the results is sent to the list. Web pages
>>containing the results are generated at the same time. See
>>www.pab.gtld-mou.org/votes/index.html
>
>>As you can see the ballots are completely open once the voting
>>period has ended. This allows everyone to verify that their vote
>>was counted as cast. Members may only protest their own ballot.
>>In the event of a protest, the original ballots complete with full
>>headers are available for audit
>
>>The voting software was prepared by Dan Busarow.
>
>>-------------------------------------------------------------
>
>>--
>>Kent Crispin, PAB Chair "No reason to get excited",
>>kent@songbird.com the thief he kindly spoke...
>>PGP fingerprint: B1 8B 72 ED 55 21 5E 44 61 F4 58 0F 72 10 65
>>55 http://songbird.com/kent/pgp_key.html
>
>
>Bill Semich
>General Manager
>The .NU Domain
>bsemich@mail.nu
>http://www.nunames.nu
>".NU - The un.com(mon) domain"
>
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Sun Jan 30 2000 - 03:22:21 PST